RIU Music Buy me a coffee DE

Reading · Piano · Lesson 18

Reharmonization on Piano: One Note, Many Chords

How to put new chords under an existing melody at the piano, from the line cliché to tritone substitution, and the checks that tell you whether a swap holds up.

684 words3 min read

The exercise I used to get back into reharmonization after the long break needs a single finger of the right hand. The little finger holds a high E, and the left hand changes chords underneath: C, then Em, then Am, then Fmaj7, then Dm9, then B♭maj7♯11. The E stays on the same key, but it is in turn the third, the root, the fifth, the seventh, the ninth and the ♯11. Nothing about the melody has changed, and yet every bar sounds like a different world. That is the core of reharmonization: an existing melody gets new chords. Substitution is the same thing on a small scale, one chord swapped for another with a similar function or similar notes. Jazz knows dozens of procedures for this; for songwriting six are enough.

One finger moves, the rest stays

The second technique turns the principle around: the chord stands still and a single note moves chromatically. Am–Am(maj7)–Am7–Am6 is the best-known example, the line cliché. The right hand holds C and E, the little finger leads the top voice from A through G♯ and G to F♯, and the left hand stays on the A in the bass. The major counterpart is C–Caug–C6–C7, where the fifth climbs from G by half steps all the way to B♭. There is no change of function, but there is motion, and that will carry a whole verse before the chorus brings the first real chord change. At the piano the cliché shows especially clearly what almost all substitutions have in common: they replace leaps with half steps, in one hand or in both.

The left hand moves one key

In tritone substitution the half step is in the left hand. Instead of Dm7–G7–Cmaj7 I play Dm7–D♭7–Cmaj7: the bass falls D, D♭, C instead of D, G, C. This works because both chords contain the same tritone: G7 has B and F, D♭7 has F and C♭, and C♭ on the piano is the same key as B. The right hand can almost stay where it is; in my voicing only the G moves to A♭. In pop, ♭II7 rarely acts as a real dominant and mostly as a chromatic passing chord. Passing diminished chords are related: when two diatonic chords lie a whole step apart, a diminished seventh fits on the key between them, C♯°7 between C and Dm, say, or F♯°7 between F and G; each of them is a secondary dominant without its root, C♯°7 being an A7♭9 in all but name. The backdoor dominant takes the other road to the tonic: Fm7–B♭7–C, that is ♭VII7 instead of V7, the sound of many Beatles endings and the standard cadence in gospel and soul. It is softer because the leading tone is missing; the A♭ falls to the fifth and the B♭ rises to the root.

The simplest form and the cross-check

The most harmless substitution is one I knew from harmony class as a piece of function theory, without ever having used it as a tool for reharmonizing: the diatonic kind. Chords that share two of their three notes stand in for each other, I with vi and with iii, IV with ii, V with vii°. I–IV–V–I becomes iii–ii–V–vi and the melody still fits, without a single black key entering the picture. Only vi and iii between themselves share just one note, so they are better swapped by way of the I. Before any swap, three things need checking: that the melody note sits in the new chord or forms a sensible extension of it, that the bass line becomes stepwise or stays put, and that the new chord resolves to where the old one was heading. Three yeses, and the swap stays. One no, and you change the melody, the bass or the target chord, or look for another replacement.

In the lesson every technique has a playable example, the line cliché and the tritone substitution as piano rolls for both hands, the note E under six chords to listen along with, plus the exercise of harmonizing the last bar before your own tonic four different ways.

The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 18 · Substitution and reharmonization.

Open lesson 18 in the Piano course

Same topic on the guitar: Chord Substitution and Reharmonization on Guitar