RIU Music Buy me a coffee DE

Reading · Guitar · Lesson 18

Chord Substitution and Reharmonization on Guitar

Six ways to swap one chord for another that does the same job, from tritone substitution to the line cliché, and the three questions to ask before any swap.

698 words3 min read

Replace the G7 before the tonic in C major with a D♭7 and on the guitar you are playing the same barre shape six frets lower: the A-shape seventh chord slides from the tenth fret to the fourth. The chord sounds foreign, yet it resolves to C just as well, because the two notes that matter are unchanged. That is substitution: one chord swapped for another that does the same job or holds the same important notes. Reharmonization is the same thing on a larger scale, an existing melody gets new chords. Jazz has dozens of techniques for this; for pop and songwriting six are enough.

Three questions before any swap

Before replacing a chord, three checks pay off. Is the melody note in the new chord, or a sensible extension of it, a ninth, eleventh or thirteenth? Does the bass line become stepwise, or at least stay put, instead of leaping? And does the new chord resolve to where the old one was heading? Three yeses and the swap works; one no means adjusting melody, bass or target chord, or finding another replacement. In the simplest swap, diatonic substitution within the functional families, chords that share two of their three notes stand in for each other: I, vi and iii as tonic, IV and ii as subdominant, V and vii° as dominant. I–IV–V–I turns into iii–ii–V–vi and the melody still fits, as long as its note is one of the shared tones. An E or a G over the C allows Em; a C does not.

Half steps instead of leaps

Three of the six techniques share one signature on the fretboard: they replace leaps of a fifth in the bass with half steps. Tritone substitution is the case from the opening. G7 and D♭7 share their tritone, B and F in one, F and C♭ in the other, and C♭ on a guitar is simply the same fret as B. So ♭II7 can stand in for V7, Dm7–D♭7–Cmaj7 instead of Dm7–G7–Cmaj7, with the bass walking down chromatically. In pop the chord rarely acts as a true dominant, mostly as a chromatic passing chord. Passing diminished chords do the same between two diatonic chords a whole step apart: C–C♯°7–Dm or F–F♯°7–G. Each is also a secondary dominant without its root; C♯°7 amounts to an A7♭9. The line cliché keeps the chord in place while a single note travels: C–Caug–C6–C7, where the fifth G rises through G♯ and A to B♭, or Am–Am(maj7)–Am7–Am6, where a voice falls from the root A through G♯ and G to F♯ over a bass that stays on A. On the guitar that line runs down the G string for three chords, second fret, first fret, open string, then lands on F♯ at the fourth fret of the D string for Am6. The C7 closing the major cliché is also the V/IV, which is why the progression lands on F so naturally.

The back door and a single melody note

The backdoor dominant is the ♭VII chord as a seventh chord, B♭7 in C, often with its own ii in front: Fm7–B♭7–C. It sits behind many Beatles endings and is the standard move in gospel and soul, and it sounds softer than V7 to I because no leading tone pulls: the A♭ falls to the fifth, G, the F to the third, E, and the B♭ rises a whole step to the root. The most radical technique turns the perspective around. A single melody note is read in turn as the root, third, fifth, seventh, ninth, ♯11 or 13 of different chords. The note E is the root of Em, the third of C, the fifth of Am, the seventh of Fmaj7, the ninth of Dm9, the ♯11 of B♭maj7♯11 and the 13 of G13. Film music lives on this; pop uses it mostly in the last chorus, when the familiar melody stands over new chords.

The lesson turns these descriptions into sound: each technique plays as a pair of original and replacement, the line cliché as a tab with chord diagrams, and the note E runs audibly under seven chords before you put the three questions to a progression of your own.

The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 18 · Substitution and reharmonization.

Open lesson 18 in the Guitar course

Same topic on the piano: Reharmonization on Piano: One Note, Many Chords