RIU Music Buy me a coffee DE

Reading · Guitar · Lesson 17

Modal Interchange on Guitar: Borrowed Chords in Major

What modal interchange means, which six chords you borrow from the parallel minor, and the three progressions you hear everywhere. With chord diagrams.

699 words3 min read

On the guitar, modal interchange starts for me as a change of grip: F to Fm. In C major I hold the F barre at the first fret, lift my middle finger off the G string, and the A at the second fret becomes the A♭ at the first. One finger less, and the chord tips over. That is the whole mechanism behind the term: you stay in C major but borrow a chord from C minor, the key with the same root. The course calls it the parallel key, and when I first met the term in English tutorials I confused it with the relative key, A minor, since the German word for relative is Paralleltonart. Borrowing almost always happens from the parallel side, not the relative one.

FFmC×
IV–iv–I in C: only the finger on the G string moves, from A to A♭.

Which chords you take

C minor brings three notes that C major does not have: E♭, A♭ and B♭. Every borrowed chord contains at least one of them, and that note is exactly what you hear. The list is short. Fm is the minor subdominant, iv. A♭ is ♭VI, B♭ is ♭VII, E♭ is ♭III. Then there is the half-diminished Dm7♭5 as a darker ii before the dominant, and as a special case D♭ as ♭II, which comes from Phrygian rather than from C minor and is known in classical harmony as the Neapolitan. In Nashville numbers that reads 4m, ♭6, ♭7, ♭3, 2m7♭5 and ♭2. On the fretboard most of these are barre chords: Fm with the barre at the first fret, A♭ as an E shape at the fourth, B♭ and E♭ as A shapes at the first and the sixth fret. Once the two barre shapes are under your fingers, the major borrowed chords are available in every key, because their distance from the tonic never changes.

Three progressions you hear constantly

IV–iv–I is the ballad gesture par excellence. F to Fm moves only the A down to A♭, and that note is the ♭6 of the key, the saddest note in the major system. From there it falls to the fifth, G, as soon as C arrives. ♭VI–♭VII–I runs the other way: A♭, B♭, C, two whole steps up into the tonic. The progression reaches home without a leading tone, by heaving itself up, which is why it sounds like a build before the last chorus or like the end of a film; gamers know it as the Mario cadence. The third is I–♭VII–IV, in E major that is E, D, A. The ♭VII is the most borrowed chord of all; in de Clercq and Temperley's rock corpus it accounts for roughly eight percent of all chords and sits with vi among the most common chords after I, IV and V. Strictly speaking it turns the key Mixolydian; in practice the key stays major as long as the V keeps showing up.

Where the line is

In my first attempts at writing songs I borrowed too much. One borrowed chord per phrase works; three in a row stop being a touch of color and become a move to minor. A single Cm in a C major song is still a borrowed chord; a whole verse in Cm is a change to the parallel key. The second point is resolution: the borrowed note wants to move a half step down or to the nearest chord tone. The A♭ from Fm or from A♭ major goes to G; the B♭ from B♭ major goes chromatically up to B or down to A. If the melody carries that motion, the chord more or less takes care of itself. And the reverse case, major chords in minor, is not filed under modal interchange: the major dominant in minor belongs to harmonic minor, the major subdominant in minor is Dorian, and the major tonic at the end of a minor piece is the Picardy third.

On the page all of this stays theory about A♭ and G. In the lesson you can see the six borrowed chords as chord diagrams, play each of the three progressions in C and in G, and run them through six keys with a trainer until the change from IV to iv happens on its own.

The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 17 · Modal interchange: minor colors in major.

Open lesson 17 in the Guitar course

Same topic on the piano: Modal Interchange on Piano: Borrowed Chords and Black Keys