Minor Scales on the Piano and the Chords of a Minor Key
Relative and parallel minor explained, the three minor scales counted in black keys, and the single key that turns the soft minor v chord into an E7.
Am–F–C–G and C–G–Am–F are the same four chords. Which of the two keys a piece is in, A minor or C major, cannot be read off the keyboard; it comes down to three things: where the loop starts, on which note the melody settles, and whether an E or E7 appears anywhere. Whichever chord opens the loop gets treated as the tonic. A phrase that ends on A pulls toward minor, one that ends on C toward major. And E7 is the dominant in A minor, while in C major it is only a visitor, explainable as a secondary dominant and nothing more. If it keeps coming back and resolves to Am every time, the piece is in minor. Many pop songs leave the question unanswered on purpose: the verse sits on the minor chord, the chorus moves to the major one, and the latter sounds brighter although not a single chord is new.
Two kinds of kinship
The relationship between A minor and C major is called the relative key: same notes, same key signature, the minor key starting on the sixth degree. Then there is the parallel key: C minor shares its root with C major but only four of its notes. German textbooks swap the words, calling A minor the "parallel" key of C major and C minor the "variant" key, so anyone reading in both languages has to translate in their head. For writing, both relationships matter: the relative one for the contrast between verse and chorus, the parallel one for borrowed chords.
One more black key
Natural minor on A is the simplest scale on the keyboard: white keys only, A B C D E F G, counted in degrees 1 2 ♭3 4 5 ♭6 ♭7. Harmonic minor adds one black key, G♯ instead of G. That brings in the leading tone, the key directly beneath the root. Between F and G♯, however, an augmented second opens up, three half steps, a gap whose sound one associates at once with classical music or the Middle East. Melodic minor closes it with a second black key, F♯ instead of F: A B C D E F♯ G♯. In the classical tradition this form applies only going up; coming down you play natural minor again. In jazz it applies in both directions and is often called jazz minor. On the keyboard, then, the difference between the three scales is simply the number of black keys: none, one, two.
The third rises a half step
Stack a triad over each degree of the natural minor scale and you have i, ii°, ♭III, iv, v, ♭VI, ♭VII; in A minor that means Am, B°, C, Dm, Em, F, G. The dominant v is minor, and going from Em back to Am feels soft, almost modal, because no note is pulling toward A. This is why nearly all minor progressions fetch their E or E7 from harmonic minor. In the right hand this is a single motion: the third G moves to the black key G♯, and for E7 the seventh D is added. The same in B minor, where Bm becomes B7 when D rises to D♯ and A joins in. A minor key therefore offers two dominants: v for rock and folk, V7 for pull and drama, and it pays to play every progression with both before deciding.
The loops that result are carried by the left hand in the bass. The Andalusian cadence Am–G–F–E is a descent that ends on the dominant. Am–F–E7 moves the bass by a half step from F to E and sounds dramatic. Am–G–F–G has no leading tone and circles. And Am–Dm–G–C falls in fifths and drifts toward C major, the relative key, which brings you back to the question from the start.
The lesson plays the three scales and both dominants one after the other, shows the progressions in six minor keys with keyboard diagrams for both hands, and has the change from Em to E7 as a notation example to play along with. There you can compare soft and driving directly, with both hands on the keys.
The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 13 · Minor: three scales, two dominants.
Open lesson 13 in the Piano courseSame topic on the guitar: Minor Scales on Guitar and the Two Dominant Chords