RIU Music Buy me a coffee DE

Reading · Piano · Lesson 14

Secondary Dominants on the Piano, One Black Key Each

How secondary dominants work, why in C major each of them adds exactly one black key, and how both hands carry the pull toward the target chord.

715 words4 min read

In C major the five secondary dominants are easy to spot on the piano: each one has exactly one black key, and every time it is the third. A7 has C♯, B7 has D♯ with an F♯ as its fifth on top, D7 has F♯, E7 has G♯, and C7 is the only one with a lowered note, B♭. When I was trained, these chords went by the German name Zwischendominante, and the explanation was the same then as now: the black key is a leading tone every time, just not to the tonic but to one of the other degrees. What is new to me after the long break is only the notation with the slash.

Five of x

A secondary dominant is a major or dominant seventh chord that does not belong to the key but sits a fifth above a diatonic chord and leads into it; V7/x is read "five of x". In C major: A7 to Dm is V7/ii, B7 to Em is V7/iii, C7 to F is V7/IV, D7 to G is V7/V, also known as the dominant of the dominant, and E7 to Am is V7/vi. There is no dominant for the diminished chord on the seventh degree, because a diminished triad is not a destination, and V/I is simply the ordinary dominant G7. Five, then, and B7 with its two foreign notes is the most distant and rarest.

Third up, seventh down

The pull toward the target has two voices on the piano, and both can be followed one finger at a time in the right hand. The third of the secondary dominant sits a half step below the root of the target and rises to it: C♯ to D when A7 goes to Dm. The seventh sits above the third of the target and falls onto it, by a half or a whole step: G to F in the same resolution. Everything else stays where it is. Watch this once with two fingers and it is clear why secondary dominants are mostly written as seventh chords: without the seventh, C7 would just be C major, the tonic, and only the B♭ makes it a dominant of F.

From the diatonic chord to its secondary dominant is one key, two at most. Em becomes E7 when G moves to G♯ and D is added. Am becomes A7 when C moves to C♯ and G is added. Dm becomes D7 when F moves to F♯ and C is added. The rule: the minor chord of the key plus the third raised a half step gives the secondary dominant, and the target lies a fifth below. The left hand makes that falling fifth in the bass; the right hand lifts one finger onto the black key and drops it back onto the white one at the target chord. I practice this as a chain through the whole cadence: C, E7, Am, A7, Dm, D7, G7, C. Every secondary dominant raises a third, every target takes it back.

Chains, detours and relatives

Line up nothing but dominant seventh chords and you get the ragtime progression I–VI7–II7–V7, in C: C–A7–D7–G7. It is the bridge of many jazz standards and sounds like retro in a pop context. The resolution can also be redirected; the lesson cites "Don't Look Back in Anger", where the E7 as V7/vi in C major does not continue to Am but to F, a deceptive cadence from the point of view of the secondary key. A relative is the secondary diminished seventh chord: C♯°7 instead of A7 before Dm, the same leading-tone logic, a thinner sound, often as a chromatic passing step in the bass. And in front of every secondary dominant you can place its own second degree, Em7–A7–Dm7, which is how jazz and bossa nova build long, wandering progressions. For writing, one is usually enough: put a dominant in front of every chord of I–vi–ii–V, then cut until it sounds like pop instead of Dixieland, and as a rule exactly one is left.

In the lesson all five secondary dominants can be heard with their resolutions, viewed as keyboard diagrams for both hands, and played through in six keys. The notation example with the full chain shows which finger lifts when, and when it comes back down.

The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 14 · Borrowed dominants: V of x.

Open lesson 14 in the Piano course

Same topic on the guitar: Secondary Dominants on Guitar, One Fret Away