Minor Scales on Guitar and the Two Dominant Chords
Natural, harmonic and melodic minor compared, the chord set of a minor key, and why nearly every minor progression has to choose between Em and E7.
Em to E, one finger: G string open, then G string first fret, G becomes G♯. That the three minor scales, natural, harmonic and melodic, differ by only one or two notes was something I knew from the piano, where it comes down to one more black key. What was new to me was where that note lives on six strings, and it sits in exactly this fret. It turns the soft minor dominant v into the major dominant V, and that is precisely the difference between natural and harmonic minor.
Three scales, one root
Natural minor is the major scale of the relative key, played from its sixth degree: A minor has the same notes as C major, A B C D E F G, as degrees 1 2 ♭3 4 5 ♭6 ♭7. On the fretboard that means anyone who knows the C major patterns already knows A minor; only the resting point slides three frets down. Harmonic minor raises the seventh degree, G to G♯, and gains the leading tone, the note a half step below the root. The price is the leap from F to G♯, three frets on one string, an augmented second that immediately sounds classical or Middle Eastern. Melodic minor therefore raises the sixth degree as well, F to F♯, and smooths out the gap: A B C D E F♯ G♯. In classical theory this form is used only ascending; in jazz it goes both ways.
Why a minor key has two dominants
The seven degrees of natural minor carry the triads i, ii°, ♭III, iv, v, ♭VI and ♭VII, in A minor Am, B°, C, Dm, Em, F and G. The fifth degree is minor. Em to Am sounds soft, almost modal, because no leading tone pulls toward A. That is why practically every minor progression borrows its dominant from harmonic minor: E or E7. The result is two dominants to choose from, v for a rock or folk character, V7 for pull and drama. I now play every minor progression twice, once with Em and once with E7, and only then decide. A barred Bm works the same way: the finger on the B string moves from the third fret to the fourth, D becomes D♯, and Bm turns into B.
The typical loops fall out of the chord set almost by themselves. Am–F–C–G is the four-chord minor loop, the same shapes as C–G–Am–F, just started in a different place. Am–G–F–E is the Andalusian cadence, a bass descent that lands on the dominant. Am–G–F–G stays purely Aeolian and circles, because the leading tone is missing. And Bm7♭5–E7–Am is the ii–V–i of jazz, the minor form of the cadence, in which the second degree is half-diminished.
Major or minor, same shapes
The question that stays open most often with songs learned from tabs: does a song built on Am, F, C and G live in A minor or in C major? The chords alone will not tell you. Three things decide it. First, where the loop starts, because the first chord carries the weight of a tonic. Second, where the melody comes to rest, on A or on C. Third, whether E or E7 shows up: in C major, E7 could only be explained as a secondary dominant, and as a permanent guest it points to A minor. Many songs keep this deliberately open, verse on the minor chord, chorus on the major one, and the chorus sounds brighter without a single new shape being played.
What is missing here is the listening. In the lesson the three scales sit side by side as audio examples, the progressions can be played in six minor keys with chord diagrams, and the change from v to V is written out as tab with diagrams, along with the chromatic bass descent over slash chords. The course is free, and lesson 13 is the entry point for everything that happens with minor keys from there on.
The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 13 · Minor: three scales, two dominants.
Open lesson 13 in the Guitar courseSame topic on the piano: Minor Scales on the Piano and the Chords of a Minor Key