RIU Music Buy me a coffee DE

Reading · Piano · Lesson 25

Melody Analysis at the Piano: Degrees and Non-Chord Tones

Taking a melody apart at the piano in six steps: what separates passing tones, neighbor tones and suspensions, and why the left hand decides what a note means.

717 words4 min read

Between Beethoven's “Ode to Joy” of 1824 and the tune “New Britain” of 1835, the one “Amazing Grace” is sung to, lie eleven years and two opposite ways of building a melody. One stays inside a fifth and knows only stepwise motion; the other spans an octave, leaps fourths and thirds, and gets by on the five notes of the major pentatonic. That both work comes down to the same underlying principles, and those become visible once you take the melodies apart instead of just playing them.

Right hand melody, left hand meaning

At the piano, analysis has an advantage singers and horn players lack: the right hand plays the melody, the left puts the root of the bar's chord underneath, and the relationship between the two is audible in a single stroke. Every melody note is either a chord tone or a non-chord tone, and the left hand decides which. An E over C is the third; the same note over G is a sixth that does not belong to the triad and wants to resolve down to D. The note has not moved; its meaning has.

Three kinds of non-chord tone cover almost everything. The passing tone runs stepwise between two chord tones, usually on a weak beat; when it lands on a strong beat it is called an accented passing tone. The neighbor tone moves one step away from a chord tone and returns to the same note, 1–2–1 or 3–4–3. If it moves away and then leaps off instead of returning, it leaves its return unpaid; the technical term is échappée. The suspension, finally, sits on the strong beat, is foreign to the chord, and resolves stepwise, usually downward, into a chord tone. The lesson has you try exactly this: a single bar of the Ode, once harmonized over C and G, once entirely over G, the same keys in the right hand, and the held 3 turns from chord tone into suspension.

Six steps, one order

The lesson's procedure does not begin with non-chord tones but before them. First, key and range: lowest and highest note, tonic, scale. Second, write every note as a degree from 1 to 7, because only then can two melodies in different keys be compared; at the piano that means mentally rotating the keyboard onto the tonic so the white and black keys get numbers. Third, mark the chord tones as described above. Fourth, look for the motif, the smallest unit that recurs, and note whether it comes back as a sequence, in inversion, or rhythmically varied. Fifth, phrases and contour: length, open or closed ending, position of the high point. Sixth, the rhythmic profile and the place where it breaks.

The order is not arbitrary. Start with the motif before the degrees are in place and you will find repetitions of pitches but not of functions. In the Ode, for instance, the second four-bar phrase is identical to the first except for its ending: the first closes on 2 over the dominant and stays open, the second lands on 1. That is a period with a half cadence and a full cadence, question and answer, and you only see it in degrees. In “Amazing Grace” the degrees show that two leaps in the same direction, a fourth and a third upward, are then caught by steps downward, a pattern melodies have shared across centuries.

What stays with you

What the method is good for showed itself on an attempt of my own: a small melody, nothing serious, that would not hold together, and I could not say why. Written in degrees, the finding was banal: no high point, every phrase ended closed, and the motif never came back varied. The Ode has a range of a fifth and a single dotted rhythm, and that one sits at the cadence. Evidently it takes little when contour, repetition, and question and answer are in place.

The lesson lays out both melodies as playable scores labeled with degrees and with bass notes in the left hand, plus the comparison bar with the suspension and an exercise that puts the Ode's degree profile over Am, F, C and G. There the difference between chord tone and suspension is not a definition but two bars you strike one after the other.

The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 25 · Taking melodies apart.

Open lesson 25 in the Piano course

Same topic on the guitar: How to Analyze a Melody on Guitar in Six Steps