RIU Music Buy me a coffee DE

Reading · Piano · Lesson 26

Analyzing Hits at the Piano: Seven Questions per Song

Why hit chord progressions feel so alike at the piano, what corpus data says about it, and how seven questions find the trick that lifts a song off the formula.

761 words4 min read

When I work out a song at the piano, I usually arrive within a few bars at four chords I already know from a dozen other songs. That déjà vu is not a sign of lazy songwriters; it is measurable. In the rock corpus by de Clercq and Temperley, I, IV and V together make up about 72 percent of all chords, ♭VII and vi another 15. Six degrees cover 91 percent. Analyzing hits is therefore less about finding the chords than about finding out what a song does with them.

IG›IIIB›IVC›ivCm
The loop from “Creep” in G major: two of the four chords lie outside the key, and the top voice of the right hand moves D, D♯, E, E♭.

The statistics behind the déjà vu

The numbers come from three sources of very different quality. The rock corpus, 100 songs from the Rolling Stone 500 list in the 2011 study and 200 in the 2013 extension, was annotated by ear by two theorists working independently. The McGill Billboard dataset draws about 740 songs at random from the Hot 100 between 1958 and 1991 and so has the cleanest sample. Hooktheory collects tens of thousands of user-transcribed songs, which means above all what hobby musicians want to play. Because the clean corpora end around 1991 and 2000, everything about charts after 2010 rests on Hooktheory alone. The basic findings have not weakened there: four chords, loops, hardly any inversions, I–V–vi–IV and its rotations as the most common four-chord loop.

Two findings changed how I listen. First, the plagal move IV to I is more common in the rock corpus than V to I, and falling and rising fifths occur equally often. Pop is not functionally directed the way classical music is, and anyone who grew up at the piano with cadence theory at first hears something missing in loops where nothing is missing. Second, 94 percent of all chords are in root position.

Inversions are rare, which is why you hear them

For pianists that second finding is the more important one. Inversions sit so comfortably under the hand at the piano that you play them by reflex and use up exactly the device hits spend sparingly. In “Let It Be” every chord is diatonic, and the one harmonic event of the verse is a G/B that lets the left hand's bass fall stepwise; the chorus brings the same chords without that inversion, and already it tells them differently. One third in the bass at the right spot, that is the dose.

The counterpart is loops held together not by the bass but by an inner voice. In the loop from “Creep”, I–III–IV–iv in G major, two of the four chords are outside the key: B as a chromatic mediant and Cm as a chord borrowed from G minor. Play the four chords in the right hand so the top voice runs D, D♯, E and E♭ while the left hand lays down roots only, and the pull explains itself; the chord symbols say nothing about it.

Applying the grid at the piano

The lesson sets out seven questions in a fixed order. Where is home, major, minor, mixolydian, ambiguous? What is the form in letters and bar counts, and when does the first chorus arrive? What progression does each section have in degrees, and how many chords per bar? Which chords are non-diatonic, and what are they doing there? What does the melody look like, range, scale, hook position, high point? What enters the arrangement when, and where is the break? And finally: which single element lifts the song off the formula? At the piano, questions three and four can be answered with the left hand alone, roots in time, because sequences show themselves fastest that way; in “Hotel California” the verse is a two-chord model repeated twice a whole step lower before it cadences, and you hear that in the bass before you reach for a triad.

The seventh question is the only one without a table. In “Smells Like Teen Spirit” the trick is that power chords without thirds leave open whether the loop is major or minor, and that the ♭VI sits at the end of the loop where the ear expects a dominant. At the piano you can recreate that by playing the same loop once with a minor third on the iv and once with a major third. That comparison sits in the lesson as two buttons side by side, next to the Creep loop as a score with its chromatic top voice, the chord grids of all four songs in degrees, and the statistics as a chart. From there it is a short step to the next three songs from your own playlist.

The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 26 · Hits under the microscope.

Open lesson 26 in the Piano course

Same topic on the guitar: Analyzing Hit Songs: Chord Progressions and the Data