Finding melodies at the piano, chord in the left hand
Stable and unstable scale degrees, question and answer, chord tones and neighboring keys, contour and hook. How a singable melody comes together at the piano.
Two phrases, the same first five notes, C4 up to G4 by step. One then keeps climbing and stops on B4; the other turns around and lands back on C4. Played one after the other, the first sounds like a sentence cut off mid-word, the second like a full stop. That is the core of what makes a melody singable and memorable, and the rules behind it fit on one page.
Stable degrees, open phrases
Each of the seven degrees of the key has a weight of its own, regardless of which chord is under the left hand at the moment. The stable ones are degrees 1, 3 and 5; a phrase may come to rest there. Degrees 2, 4 and 6 push onward, 2 to 1 or 3, 4 to 3, 6 to 5. 7 is the most restless and pulls toward 1. A phrase that ends on 2 or 7 sounds like a continuation; one that ends on 1 or 3 sounds like a conclusion. Out of this comes the oldest building principle in melody, question and answer. The question ends open, on degree 2, 5 or 7, usually with V in the left hand; the answer ends on 1 or 3 over I. Pop never gave this up: the first two lines of a verse pose the question, the next two give the answer, and in the chorus the answer is the title.
Chord on the left, neighboring keys on the right
The second rule concerns the strong beats. Wherever the left hand takes a new chord, and on beats 1 and 3, the right hand should be on a note of that chord; between those points almost anything is allowed. A passing tone links two chord tones via the key between them, a neighbor tone steps one key away and back, an anticipation brings in the next chord tone early. The suspension turns the rule around once: a note that does not belong to the chord sits on the strong beat and only afterwards resolves by step, the strongest emotional gesture a melody has, and the melodic twin of the sus4 chord.
At the piano this is the fastest way to find melodies. The left hand holds the chord, for C say root and fifth, C3 and G3. The right hand plays the chord tones E, G and C as targets and the white keys next to them, D and F, as passing tones. The lesson demonstrates this with an example melody over the sequence C, G, Am, F, and there every strong beat carries a chord tone, with one exception: bar two opens with C over G, a non-chord tone, and resolves to B. Play nothing but chord tones and what you get is an arpeggio; lean on the third and use the sixth and ninth as passing tones and suspensions and what you get is a melody. It is the same mechanism as improvising over changes, one I know from jazz school but never applied there to vocal melodies: land on the chord tone, move with the neighbor.
Contour, motif and the hook
A hit melody rarely needs more than an octave to an octave and a half of range, and its shape can be named: arch, wave or terrace, where the terrace puts the chorus a step above the verse. Each section gets one peak, usually just before that section ends; you reach it by step or with a single leap, and a leap wider than a fourth is then balanced by steps the other way. The raw material is a short motif, two to five notes, that you sequence, shift rhythmically, invert or shorten. Twice the same, the third time different: the rule holds from Beethoven to the radio.
The hook is what you hum after a single listen: two to four bars long, with a distinctive rhythm, tonally kept simple and frequently pentatonic, and it comes round three times or more within the chorus. Whether a hook sticks depends more on its rhythm than on its pitches; stressed syllables belong on strong beats, long notes on important words, and a chorus with a pickup pulls while one that starts on the downbeat asserts. The title lives on the hook as a rule. Write the hook first and you build the rest of the song around something that already works.
The two phrases from the opening can be heard in the lesson, along with the example melody as a notation example with left hand, melody only or chords only, as well as the motif in its sequences. The practice is done with both hands over C, G, Am, F throughout.
The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 22 · Melody: contour, motif, hook.
Open lesson 22 in the Piano courseSame topic on the guitar: Writing melodies on guitar, straight out of the chord shapes