RIU Music Buy me a coffee DE

Reading · Guitar · Lesson 22

Writing melodies on guitar, straight out of the chord shapes

Chord tones on the strong beats, suspensions, question and answer, motif and hook. The rules by which melodies take shape on the fretboard.

727 words4 min read

The suspension is more familiar to me from Bach than from the radio: a non-chord tone on the strong beat that resolves one step into a chord tone. Working out pop songs by ear and from tabs, you then notice that the spot carrying the most feeling is almost always exactly that, even if nobody there calls it by the name. Writing a melody is, to a large extent, a matter of managing this kind of tension between chord tone and neighbor, and on guitar the two sit right next to each other inside the shape.

C4G4E4G4E4D4D4B3D4C4E4A4G4G4F4D4C4
The lesson's example melody over C, G, Am and F. An arch up to the A in bar three, then the suspended G over F and the descent to the root.

Chord tone on 1 and 3, anything in between

The basic rule is simpler than it sounds: on beats 1 and 3, or wherever the chord changes, there is a chord tone. In between, anything goes. A passing tone connects two chord tones stepwise, a neighbor tone steps away and comes back, an anticipation brings the next chord tone in early, and the suspension deliberately puts the foreign note on the strong beat. If you use only chord tones you are writing arpeggios; if you hit only roots and fifths you sound empty. The third is the color of the chord, and the notes around it, the ninth, the sixth, the fourth, belong on the weak beats.

On guitar this comes about on its own if you hold the chord and look for the melody inside the shape, plus one to three frets above or below on the same string. With the open C chord that means frets 0, 1 and 3 on the high e string (E, F, G) and frets 0, 1 and 3 on the B string (B, C, D). The lesson's example melody over C, G, Am and F gets by with these notes and reaches up to the fifth fret only for the E and the peak note A, so the line stays on one string. In bar four a G sits over F on the downbeat, the ninth, and resolves stepwise into the root. That is the suspension; in the graphic it is where the final descent begins.

Contour, motif, question and answer

Independent of the chord, the degrees of the key have a weight of their own. 1, 3 and 5 are stable; a phrase can end on them. 2, 4 and 6 want to move one step, and 7 pulls hardest toward 1. From this follows the principle of question and answer: the first phrase ends open, on 2, 5 or 7 and often over V, the second ends closed, on 1 or 3 over I. A phrase is left open either by the note or by the chord; 5 over V is the half cadence. Verse lines 1 and 2 ask, lines 3 and 4 answer, and the chorus answers with the title.

The contour of most hit melodies stays within one to one and a half octaves and has a readable shape: an arch, a wave, or a terrace where the chorus sits a step higher than the verse. The peak comes once per section, ideally shortly before the end, and is reached stepwise or with a single leap. Leaps larger than a fourth are then caught stepwise in the opposite direction. The building material is a motif of two to five notes that gets repeated, sequenced, shifted rhythmically, inverted or shortened; "twice the same, the third time different" is the rule that has lasted longest.

What a hook is

A hook is what stays with you after one listen: two to four bars, rhythmically unmistakable, tonally simple and often pentatonic, at least three times per chorus. Rhythm decides more here than pitch. A chorus that starts on a pickup before the downbeat pulls; one that starts exactly on 1 asserts. The title almost always sits on the hook, and whoever writes the hook first and builds the rest around it gets to usable songs faster. In your own first attempts the opposite happens easily: chords first, a vocal line over them at some point, and the chorus stays interchangeable.

The example melody is there in the lesson as playable tablature with the chords underneath, melody only or chords only, along with the open and the closed phrase for comparison and the motif in sequences. The exercises all run over C, G, Am and F, with the shape under your fingers.

The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 22 · Melody: contour, motif, hook.

Open lesson 22 in the Guitar course

Same topic on the piano: Finding melodies at the piano, chord in the left hand