RIU Music Buy me a coffee DE

Reading · Piano · Lesson 7

Learning Jazz Piano with Shell and Rootless Voicings

Why jazz pianists leave out the root, how left-hand rootless voicings are built, and how to accompany ii–V–I with just a few hand shapes.

680 words3 min read

In a jazz trio the bassist plays the root. If the piano plays it too, it is only doubling. Pianists like Bill Evans and Wynton Kelly drew the obvious conclusion and left the root out: what remained was the third, fifth, seventh and one color tone, played by the left hand around middle C. These rootless voicings have been the sound of jazz piano ever since, and they are one reason jazz looks so different at the piano than pop does, even though the theory is the same.

What changes compared with pop

Six habits separate jazz from blues and pop, and almost everything that seems complicated at first comes down to one of them. Four-note chords are the default; C becomes Cmaj7, Dm becomes Dm7. The basic cell is ii–V–I. The harmonic rhythm is fast, often two chords per bar, which is why the left hand needs small voicings that change quickly. The root belongs to the bass. Eighth notes swing, with the second eighth landing on the third triplet eighth, lighter than a shuffle. And improvisation runs over the changes, chord by chord.

Guide tones first, then the voicings

ii–V–I in C is Dm7 – G7 – Cmaj7. The cadence sounds smooth because two voices carry it: the third of one chord becomes the seventh of the next, and the seventh falls a half step to the new third. F and C in Dm7, then F and B in G7, then E and B in Cmaj7. At the piano the left hand learns these guide tones first, as two notes of which only one moves at each change.

Three families of voicings build on that. Shell voicings are root and seventh, or root and third, in the left hand, two or three notes, in any register; the right hand adds the third and fifth. Rootless voicings replace the root with the ninth or the thirteenth, that is, the 2 or the 6 an octave up. Form A stacks 3–5–7–9, form B stacks 7–9–3–5, or 7–9–3–13 on dominants. For Dm7, form A is F A C E. For G7, form B is F A B E. Moving from one to the other takes a single finger, C to B. Drop-2 voicings spread a four-note chord across both hands by dropping the second-highest voice of the close position an octave; that produces four positions that climb the keyboard.

The left hand in time

Playing solo, the left hand replaces the bassist with a walking bass: four quarter notes per bar made of chord tones and passing notes that land on the next root, often with a chromatic approach from above, A♭ to G, D♭ to C. The right hand plays the guide tones above it, struck short, beats 2 and 4 given a little more weight. In a trio this flips around. The bass has the line, and the left hand plays the rootless voicing in a Charleston rhythm, beat 1 and the "and" of 2, or, like Red Garland, on the "and" of 2 and 4. The less the fingers travel, the better the comping sounds.

The dominant remains the place for color. Over G7 you can stack the 9 and 13, which soften the chord; ♭9, ♯9 and ♭13 make it dark, typically before a minor chord. And because G7 and D♭7 share their third and seventh, D♭7 can take its place, the tritone substitution. Anyone who wants to improvise starts with the chord tones 1–3–5–7 of each chord in one right-hand position, then the guide-tone line, then chromatic approaches. Assigning scales only pays off after that.

The lesson assumes the seventh chords and shell voicings from lesson 10. There every voicing is shown as a keyboard diagram you can click and hear: shells in the left hand with third and fifth in the right, rootless A and B for ii–V–I, four drop-2 positions of Cmaj7, a walking bass with guide tones, the Charleston rhythm with bass, five colorings of G7 resolving to C, plus a jazz blues in F and the rhythm changes to play along with.

The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 7 · Getting into jazz piano: concepts and differences.

Open lesson 7 in the Piano course

Same topic on the guitar: Starting Jazz Guitar with ii–V–I and Guide Tones