Chromatic Mediants on Piano: the Finger That Stays
Why C major to E major sounds like a jolt but not a mistake, how the shared note holds the change together, and which major chords are third-related to C.
C major to E minor and C major to E major differ by a single key on the piano, G against G♯, and yet they are worlds apart. Em is the diatonic mediant, a chord from the same key that shares two notes with C and hardly stands out. E major is a chromatic mediant: the same quality as C, exactly one shared note, and not from the key. The change is a jolt without preparation. I knew it from harmony class as third relation; as a pop device that is simply placed without any lead-in, I did not. That it still does not sound like a mistake is down to the E that sits in both chords and holds the change together while the other two notes tip the color.
The finger that does not move
On the piano this becomes a tangible rule. The shared note stays in the same voice and under the same finger; the other two slide by one key. If I play C as G, C and E in the right hand, the little finger stays on the E and for E major the other two move to G♯ and B. If I play C as C, E, G and want A♭, the thumb stays on the C, E goes to E♭ and G to A♭. The foreign chord becomes a shift rather than a leap, and that is the trick film music and Radiohead use alike. Grab the mediant fresh in another position and you hear the leap but not the thread.
Four directions from C
From C major there are four chromatic major mediants, a major and a minor third in each direction. E major lies a major third up, shared note E, degree III, bright like a lens opening. E♭ major lies a minor third up, shared note G, degree ♭III, the heroic rock chord. A major lies a minor third down, shared note E again, degree VI, warm and surprising. A♭ major lies a major third down, shared note C, degree ♭VI, dark and wide, the film-score chord. Between minor chords the same logic holds, Am to Cm for instance. What stands out is that all four already have another name: E♭ and A♭ are chords borrowed from C minor, E and A are the secondary dominants V/vi and V/ii. What makes them mediants is the treatment. The secondary dominant resolves, E7 goes to Am. The mediant is placed and goes straight back to C or on to the next third-related chord.
Turning the chain further
Because every step keeps one note, mediants can be strung together without a center forming. C–E–A♭–C divides the octave into three major thirds and is the axis of Coltrane's “Giant Steps”; rare in pop, a permanent guest in film music. C–E♭–G♭–A runs in minor thirds and has a diminished seventh chord as its skeleton, tension without direction. The doubly chromatic mediant, C major to E♭ minor or A♭ minor, has neither the same quality nor a shared note; it is standard in horror and fantasy scores and usable in a song only as a conscious break, at the start of a bridge or at the end.
The one note that stays is right there to see in the lesson, which shows the five chords as keyboard diagrams with the degrees written in the dots, then plays every pair, the chains and the doubly chromatic version, and has the piano roll with the resting finger ready to play before you set the same melody note over C, E, A and Am.
The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 20 · Chromatic mediants.
Open lesson 20 in the Piano courseSame topic on the guitar: Chromatic Mediants on Guitar: Chords a Third Apart