Arranging for Guitar: Registers and Density
Why two guitars playing the same open chords turn to mud, the five roles every arrangement fills, and how density carries a chorus. With chord diagrams.
My first attempt with a looper pedal sounded worse than either layer on its own. The loop held G, D, Em and C as open chords, and over it I played the same shapes once more; together they turned into a smear around the low strings. That arranging for guitar is mostly a question of register is something you hear in that smear faster than you read it in any textbook.
Five roles across the spectrum
An arrangement hands out space. Every element in a song has a role and a frequency range where it gets in nobody's way. The foundation sits roughly between 40 and 200 Hz and belongs to bass and kick: one instrument, root notes, little movement. The harmony, meaning guitar, piano or synth, fills 200 to 1000 Hz but leaves room for the voice. The melody needs 200 to 2000 Hz and has to stand clear; everything else steps aside for it. The pulse, drums or strumming, sets tempo and groove rather than pitch. And above 2000 Hz live the small sparkles, hi-hat, shaker, high arpeggios, in small doses.
The guitar straddles a border here. The open low E string sounds at 82 Hz, the A string at 110 Hz, both squarely in the foundation band. As long as nobody else plays down there, that is fine. The moment a bass joins, the low strings compete with it, and thirds below about 200 Hz blur into something without definition. The fix is on the instrument itself: mute the low strings, put on a capo, or move to the top strings.
Never two guitars on the same voicing
From this follows the most important rule for guitarists who play in pairs or double themselves: two guitars never play the same chord with the same grip. One plays open chords; the other plays the same chords as barre shapes higher up, as triads on the top three strings, or with a capo and different shapes. For G, D, Em and C that might look like this: guitar 1 open, guitar 2 with a capo at the 7th fret playing C, G, Am and F shapes, which sound as G, D, Em and C, and guitar 3 playing triads between the 7th and 11th fret on the e, B and G strings. Three registers, one chord, no smear. The same principle applies between guitar and piano: whoever shares a register shares the mud.
What throws you at first is how thin those high-string triads sound on their own, almost like nothing. Only over the loop with the open-position guitar, or over a bass, do they become what you hear on records as shine.
Density instead of new chords
A song's form becomes audible when elements enter or drop out from section to section. The rule is short: every chorus has more than the verse before it, and every chorus has at least as much as the chorus before it. For that to work, the first verse has to be thin, thinner than feels comfortable when you play alone. Before the last chorus you strip almost everything away once so the re-entry carries. A break of one beat or half a bar before the chorus is the cheapest and most reliable lift there is.
Then there are tools that need no new chord at all. The chorus can change chords twice as fast as the verse, or half as fast. An open D or E string ringing under changing chords holds a verse together and lets the chorus open up the moment it disappears. A second line that moves against the melody and speaks in its rests. And four chords with add9, sus2, sus4 and slash variants sound more varied than eight chords in root position. “With or Without You” runs four minutes on four chords, and its form comes entirely from what is layered on, one element at a time.
The lesson on this topic holds a density grid for a verse-chorus song, the three versions of G, D, Em, C as tab with chord diagrams, and a player that lets you switch two or three guitars on and off, each with its own pattern and its own place in the stereo field. There you can hear the difference between two identical registers and two separate ones instead of reading about it.
The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 24 · Arrangement: roles, registers, arc.
Open lesson 24 in the Guitar courseSame topic on the piano: Arranging at the Piano: Range, Pedal, Density