CAGED, Triads and Voice Leading on Guitar
Why a barre chord has only three different notes, how the CAGED system joins five shapes into one map of the neck, and what voice leading means on guitar.
An E-shape barre chord has six sounding strings and three different notes. The other three are doublings. I only noticed it with a looper pedal: one full barre chord in the loop and the same chord played over it again produced nothing but mud. The fix was to cut the second chord down to three strings, to a triad. I have seen chords on the fretboard differently ever since.
A triad on three adjacent strings sits in one of three positions: root position with the 1 at the bottom, first inversion with the 3 at the bottom, second inversion with the 5 at the bottom. Major and minor differ in every position by exactly one finger, the third; diminished is minor with a ♭5, one more finger. Instead of memorizing grip diagrams I remember the interval shapes. Root position is a third plus a third, first inversion a third plus a fourth, second inversion a fourth plus a third. That is enough to find any triad on any string set.
CAGED is a map, not a trick
The open chords C, A, G, E and D are five shapes that can be moved up the neck as barre chords. Every chord exists in all five shapes at five places, and they overlap without gaps, in the order C, A, G, E, D going up and then C again. Shape plus fret gives the chord: the A shape at the third fret is C, and so is the E shape at the eighth. The root sits on the A string in the C and A shapes, on the low E string in the G and E shapes, and on the D string in the D shape. Around each shape lies the matching scale pattern; the five positions of the major scale are exactly the five CAGED shapes with their neighboring notes.
For songwriters the value of CAGED is less about soloing than about the top voice. Each shape has a different highest note; for C major it is E in the C shape, G in the A shape, C in the G and E shapes, and E again in the D shape. The highest note is what the listener hears as the melody of the accompaniment. Send a progression through the shapes and you are writing a top line on the side.
Voice leading: voices instead of grips
Voice leading means treating every note of a chord as a voice of its own that takes the shortest route to the next chord. Common tones stay, the rest move by step. With open chords this is hard to control; the top voice of C, Am, F and G in open position falls wherever the grips put it, and the bass jumps along. With triads on the G, B and high E strings it can be planned. In fifth position the same progression runs with top notes G, A, A, B and back to G, no step larger than a whole tone. In open position it gives E, E, F, G. Both versions barely move, and both sound like an accompaniment that was written rather than grabbed.
What matters in pop
In pop progressions, three things from all this matter most. First, plan the top voice, because a line that moves by step or stays put sounds composed. Second, run bass and top voice in contrary motion, bass falling C, B, A, G, top voice rising E, F, G; that is the classic device for size. Third, let common tones ring, which on guitar is easiest with open strings or with two fingers that stay down: Em7, Cadd9, G and Dsus4 with G and D at the third fret of the B and high E strings, ring finger and pinky never moving.
The lesson shows all of this on the instrument rather than in text: a triad explorer for every position and string set, C major in the five CAGED shapes with the degrees marked in the dots, a fretboard map of all chord tones up to the fifteenth fret, and I – vi – IV – V three times as playable tab, jumping with open chords, voice-led in open position and voice-led in fifth position.
The course lets you hear it: sound examples, diagrams and trainers on this topic are in Lesson 8 · Triads, CAGED and voice leading.
Open lesson 8 in the Guitar courseSame topic on the piano: Piano Chord Inversions and Voice Leading